The BMW i5 largely succeeds with its electric sedan.
There aren't many electric sedan options available, but if you're looking for luxury, the BMW i5 could be the best alternative for you.
The transition towards electrification in the automotive sector has progressed in recent years, especially in the United States, although limitations still exist regarding the variety of options available. Traditional automakers continue to adapt to electric powertrains, and while most of them have at least one electric model, the availability of electric vehicles (EVs) remains scarce compared to that of internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles.
Particularly in the electric sedan segment, priority is lower, partly due to the rising popularity of larger vehicles such as crossovers and SUVs. For those looking for an electric sedan in the U.S., the BMW i5 is a contender worth considering. While it is true that its price is high and may be out of reach for many, after testing the 2024 BMW i5 eDrive40 for a week, it can be regarded as one of the best options in its category.
Design and Luxury
The BMW i5 stands out for its luxury, a characteristic feature of the brand. The interior of the vehicle closely resembles that of the combustion engine 5 Series, which is a positive aspect. Comfort and space are notable, both in the front and rear rows, with high-quality leather seats and attractive ambient lighting. The spaciousness of the interior is one of the factors that differentiates it from the more compact i4, making it a viable option for those who frequently transport families.
The exterior design is also appealing, with a more subdued approach compared to the large grilles of some previous models, while still maintaining a distinctly BMW aesthetic. The tested unit featured the M Sport Package, which included high-end wheels and carbon fiber details, further enhancing its premium appearance.
However, cheaper sedans, such as the Ioniq 6, do not reach the level of quality and design of the i5. While other vehicles like the Lucid Air are excellent, they do not compare in terms of build and elegance, although the i4 remains its main competitor in the electric sedan segment.
Performance
The BMW i5 offers notable performance. The eDrive40 model, while not as fast as the i5 M60, has more than adequate performance for most drivers. With 335 horsepower and 295 lb-ft of torque, it accelerates from 0 to 60 mph in 5.7 seconds, being agile and responsive during driving. The Sport mode option further enhances its performance, although it reduces the vehicle's range.
The range of the eDrive40 version reaches 295 miles, according to the EPA, and it can be charged at speeds of up to 205 kW, which is considered acceptable in its category.
Technological Challenges
However, the BMW i5 also faces certain limitations. As a traditional manufacturer, BMW has not positioned itself as a technology company, and while its infotainment system has improved, it still presents usability challenges, particularly regarding climate controls that are mostly integrated into the screen. The difficulty in using Apple CarPlay during the testing week was also an inconvenience, as the vehicle's own system is somewhat confusing and outdated.
Conclusion
The BMW i5 is an outstanding electric sedan, although it is not the only valid option on the market. While the Lucid Air and other models may offer better range and software, many may prefer the interior quality of the i5. There are more economical alternatives, such as the Ioniq 6, which, although competitive in several aspects, do not match the sense of luxury and quality of the BMW i5. In summary, if one is looking for a luxury electric sedan with ample space, the i5 is worth considering.
