Hyundai Ioniq 9 vs. Tesla Model Y: Does the electric SUV surpass the best-selling electric vehicle?

The arrival of the Hyundai Ioniq 9, the highly anticipated electric SUV, is finally in sight after several months of speculation and uncertainty. This model is positioned as a direct competitor to the Kia EV9 and is shaping up to be an attractive option for those looking for a larger electric vehicle at a price lower than that of the Rivian R1S. Although it is larger than the Tesla Model Y, it is expected to be slightly more expensive. The comparison between these two models reveals notable differences in areas such as performance, range, and charging time.

Design

The design differences between the Hyundai Ioniq 9 and the Tesla Model Y are striking, which could influence purchasing decisions. The Ioniq 9 presents itself as a robust, squared SUV, with an elegant look thanks to its curved roof. The front is distinguished by a long light bar divided into blocks, giving it a unique visual signature. At the rear, pixel-shaped lights surround the trunk. With dimensions of 199.2 inches in length, 78 inches in width, and 70.5 inches in height, the Ioniq 9 is clearly more substantial.

On the other hand, while the Tesla Model Y has been on the market for some time and its design might be considered somewhat dated, it remains an attractive and modern vehicle. With its curved lines and characteristic Tesla aesthetics, it measures 187 inches in length, 76 inches in width, and 64 inches in height. The choice between the two will depend on individual design preferences.

Interior and Technology

The Ioniq 9's superior size translates into greater interior space. Both vehicles can accommodate three rows of seats, but while this configuration is standard in the Ioniq 9, it is optional in the Model Y. The third row in both models offers space for two passengers, resulting in a total capacity of seven in the Model Y and options for six or seven in the Ioniq 9. Occupants in the last row of the Ioniq 9 will enjoy more legroom and headroom.

The interior design of the Model Y follows Tesla's minimalist aesthetic, featuring a clean dashboard interrupted only by an informational screen that controls nearly all vehicle functions. In contrast, the Ioniq 9 adopts a more conventional approach with two dedicated screens; although its infotainment software is not as robust as Tesla's, it does allow integration with CarPlay and Android Auto.

Performance

The performance characteristics of both vehicles differ significantly. The Tesla Model Y is designed to offer quick acceleration, while the Ioniq 9 is oriented more towards comfort. This does not mean that the Ioniq 9 is slow; its base model comes with a 215-horsepower motor powering the rear wheels, with all-wheel-drive options that enhance performance. The most powerful version of the Ioniq 9 can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in 5.2 seconds.

The Model Y, with its Long Range Rear-Wheel Drive motor, achieves the same acceleration in 6.5 seconds, while all-wheel-drive models improve that time to 4.8 and 3.5 seconds, respectively. In this regard, Tesla takes the lead.

Range and Charging

In terms of range, while the Ioniq 9 is not yet available for purchase, Hyundai has stated that all models will offer at least 300 miles of range, reaching up to 335 miles in the Long Range RWD model. The Ioniq 9 will be capable of fast charging due to its 800-volt architecture, achieving charging speeds of up to 350 kilowatts.

The Tesla Model Y also presents comparable performance in this aspect, with ranges varying from 277 miles to 337 depending on the model. However, its maximum charging speed reaches 250 kW, meaning the Ioniq 9 has an advantage in this area.

Pricing and Availability

Regarding pricing, the Tesla Model Y is already available starting at $44,900, while the Ioniq 9, although announced, will not be on sale until early 2025 and is expected to be priced similarly to the Kia EV9, starting at around $55,000. Due to being more affordable and available, the Model Y wins this category.

Conclusion

In summary, the winner of this comparison is the Tesla Model Y, thanks to its better performance and immediate availability. However, this does not mean it is the ideal option for everyone; those seeking more space or who have larger families may find the Hyundai Ioniq 9 to be a more suitable alternative, despite the wait and additional cost it will involve.